Greenspan
10:00am 04/21/04 GREENSPAN NOT WORRIED ABOUT INFLATION YET
10:00am 04/21/04 GREENSPAN: ECONOMIC OUTLOOK IS GOOD
10:00am 04/21/04 GREENSPAN: LABOR MARKET BETTER, BUSINESS STILL CAUTIOUS
Putsar till gårdagens uttalanden, för att dämpa rädslan för kommande räntehöjning kan tänkas? Börserna drog upp på dett iaf :) Lyckad auktion, vi får se vad björne och co har att säga om detta sen...
|StRY| "Caveat emptor. Buyer beware."
Inlägget är redigerat av författaren.
#1 Hehe japp. Men det är ju så kul att se på, det här säger han för att lugna ned börsen och den stackars bonds marknaden. Vi såg ju deras lilla show igår när han uttalade sig :P
Nu säger gubben att en höjning inte behöver innebära flera. Hehe, om de inte missbedömmer läget, utan gör en korrekt bedömning så lär den första följas av en andra och en tredje. Nu kelar han bara med marknaden...
|StRY| "Caveat emptor. Buyer beware."
En liten pågende debatt mellan mig och 2 väl kända ansikten - jag är Mr A
----- Original Message -----
From: Mr A
Subject: Inflation & Greenspan's crystal ball
As long as unit labor costs are in check (-2% y-y) and labor markets are
not heating up, it can be assumed that inflation will not be a major issue (core less than 3%) Yes, some sectors will see higher prices, such as food (Beef, chicken etc), but as Greenspan says:
"...Although the recent data suggest that the worrisome trend of disinflation presumably has come to an end, still-significant productivity growth and a sizable margin of underutilized resources, to date, have checked any sustained acceleration of the general price level and should continue to do so for a time,..."
Regards,
--XXXXXX
Date: Wed, 21 Apr 2004 08:57:32 -0700
From: Mr B
Subject: Inflation & Greenspan's crystal ball
I would offer the humble opinion that listening to Greenspan's thoughts on the subject of inflation is not a statistically valid method of projecting what inflation will actually be. Remember that Greenspan took office as Fed Chairman in August 1987, and promptly produced the worst market crash in years by raising rates and by making cavalier comments about the problems this might create. Greenspan also tightened rates too far in 1989 and snuffed out the recovery that was going on from that 1987 crash, keeping the Discount Rate at 7% all the way until December 1990 even though a war-related recession was already upon us. Greenspan was credited with riding in to the rescue in 1998 during the Asian Contagion by lowering rates, but the economy would not have needed rescuing if he had lowered rates from 5% earlier and kept the liquidity crisis from developing (this was when CPI growth was around 1.5%).
Greenspan tipped the economy into recession in 2000 by keeping rates too high in order to fight inflation that was not then evident but which was believed to lie "over the horizon". Now he is keeping rates too low as "insurance" against deflation even though signs of inflation abound (as discussed well on this list). Greenspan is an amazingly intelligent and well informed person, and he is more politically astute than most of the people in DC. His PR people must be great, because even Queen Elizabeth knighted him and the financial media sing his praises. But like the emperor who bought the invisible new clothes, he nevertheless has a poor grasp on the factors which should govern the way he does his own job of setting interest rate policy to moderate inflation, and no one else but us die-hard contrarians are willing to be judged as unsuitable for their positions by pointing out that his clothes are invisible. Following his pronouncements about inflation is a good way to join him on the wrong (or at best, very late in being right) side of the curve.
-XXXXXXX
Date: Wed, 21 Apr 2004 12:59:02 -0400
From: Mr C
Subject: Inflation & Greenspan's crystal ball
Mr B - Greenspan is a technical analyst or behaviorist at heart. Just look at everything that he says. He talks about bubbles and price patterns all of the time. I once received a letter from somebody (cannot check the veracity of this) that some 40-years ago he was in a seminar with Greenspan from some cycle guru and that Greenspan follows this for stock market prices very closely.
Right now, what Greenspan sees is a basing pattern in CPI. Although prices are not a market, they are subject to supply and demand. Much as many EW types are trashed for turning bullish or bearish before there is confirmation via a breakout, that seems to be what Greenspan is doing right now regarding inflation. Inflation on non-energy items is basing and has not broken out. Waiting is probably a mistake in that if expectations start to creep in, it will be too late.
However, I still stand by my previous analyses. That is that right now the inflation pressure comes largely from commodities. This is what he got in trouble for raising rates in reaction to in 1998/1999 when oil popped. These price increases are a tax on companies and consumers. Now, the inflation bugs are out there saying that he needs to raise rates or we are in trouble.
I agree, rates are too low, but how high should they be? We are a whole lot closer to deflation and depression than many appreciate (no, I am not in the mega-EWT bear camp, never was and will not be unless the Fed hikes big time or not at all). Stocks are more over priced now than they were in 2000. The "strong" GDP data last year are at least partially due to a non-existent Q1 due to the wait for the war. All this gives nice comparisons. Greenspan needs to increase rates to get the dollar steady, which will help the inflation picture as well.
THIS IS NOT ALL GREENSPAN. Monetary policy is just part of the problem. The government is spending money like it is going out of style! That is
inflationary as well. Big time. And, the next year's budget does not even
include the cost of staying in the middle-East next year (a Republican
Congressman said the administration needs to come clean on the missing $60B and stop election year hiding of the facts this morning on TV).
Bottom line is that regardless of the games that the BLS is playing, CPI is not yet a problem. Large rate hikes will burst more bubbles than you can imagine, except Greenspan is afraid to say that for fear of bursting them. He is a behaviorist after all.
XXXXXXXXXX
Subject: Inflation & Greenspan's crystal ball
From: Mr A
".....I would offer the humble opinion that listening to Greenspan's thoughts on
the subject of inflation is not a statistically valid method of projecting what inflation will actually be...."
Assuming that popular inflation measures such as core CPI are correctly calculated and representative, I
believe that Mr Greenspan has done a good job of anticipating/balancing the act of inflation.
".....Remember that Greenspan took office as Fed Chairman in August 1987, and promptly produced the
worst market crash in years by raising rates....."
MR B - I would disagree on putting the "blame" on Greenspan per se since we have to look at the bigger picture in regards to the 1987 crash - Money supply as measured by M2, grew geometrically by 9.75% between 1982 - 1987 - thats a big number considering the average growth rate of 7% between 1962 - 1969 (Good economic years)
Knowing that M2 was one of the most important inflation indicators during that time, there is little surprise that this growth rate would finally move the CPI, which took off from 1.8% to 5% between 1987 - 1989. This move (3.2%) is big relative to the 1960's period -- Greenspan had to respond and did so initially with "only" a 0.5 point rate hike during late 1987- 1988, while the 3-month treasury bill moved from 5.5% to 7.3% PRIOR to the crash and Greenspans rate hike. The long bond moved from 7.6% to 10%. These moves were a huge pressure on the equity market as they were discounting the quick advance by the CPI, which continued to grow to 6.3% until 1991. As you say, Greenspan raised the discount rate to 7%, but this increase (from 5.5%) was well "within prior periods" of inflation relative to rate increases - Besides, the real rate between 1987 - 1989 was only 1 - 1.5%, much below the historic number of 2.75 - 3%. Had Greenspan not moved rates higher, he would have been blamed for allowing inflation run amok.
Additional reasons for the 1987 crash was due to the parabolic rise in the market prior to Greenspans rate hike. I think this needs to be factored in when we talk about what Greenspan did, or did not do - For example, 10 months prior to October 87, the market P/e was around 16. At the top in October it had risen to 23, or plus 43% in 10 months.
".....keeping the Discount Rate at 7% all the way until December 1990 even though a war-related recession was already upon us..."
Mr B, he had to - Inflation was still running fairly high until 1991 at 6.3% - Remember, it started from 1.8% 4 years earlier. And there was no guarantee that it would come down as the war-related recession was upon us - Oil prices spiked initially. After all, memories from the 70's were not so distant in terms of too much M2 and higher oil prices. Insurance policy was most likely the reason.
".....Greenspan was credited with riding in to the rescue in 1998 during the Asian Contagion by lowering rates, but the economy would not have needed rescuing if he had lowered rates from 5% earlier and kept the liquidity crisis from developing (this was when CPI growth was around 1.5%)....."
The real liquidity crisis started when the LTCM debacle became a "known" factor due to the Russian default. Initially, the Thai Bath currency was not a major thing; it was regarded as their "own little" fault late 97. So, Greenspan kept the 5% rate (real 2%) prior to 98, since this was still consistent with historic real rates at around 2.75 - 3%.
".... Greenspan tipped the economy into recession in 2000 by keeping rates too high in order to fight inflation that was not then evident but which was believed to lie "over the horizon....."
Much can be talked about whether Greenspan was the cause for tipping the economy into recession. Lets not forget that we even had a presidential candidate who constantly was trying to talk down the economy prior to 2000 - However, I still believe that the real reason for the recession was all due to its own time after several years of +4% GDP growth - The economic crash started with a bunch of internets (zero profitability) going bust in mid 1999, followed by the Telecoms who kept spending like they were making money. Again, real rates in 2000 were 2.5 - 3% (consistent with history), and that with a super-low unemployment.(3.9%) - I think its too easy to see things in hindsight, especially when many criticized Greenspan for not being more conservative.
".....Now he is keeping rates too low as "insurance" against deflation even though signs of inflation abound (as discussed well on this list)...."
Inflation in terms of commodity prices yes - but the general price level as measured by GDP deflator or core CPI is still very very low (1.4 - 1.6% y-o-y) - its still too early to conclude. What the bond market is assuming, is that the employment number of 300,000 K will lead to overnight inflation. But, its fair to argue that real rates are way too low relative to history.
Regards,
XXXXXXX
From: Mr B
Subject: Inflation & Greenspan's crystal ball
I thought that the logic of "We had to destroy the village to save it" had
gone out with the Vietnam War. Forgiving Greenspan for issuing a "full
speed ahead" command to crash the ship into the rocks just because the previous Captain had set the ship on that course (1987) is a charitable treatment of his responsibility.
The discussion was about indications of inflation, and one contributor
offered a Greenspan quote as an indication of what may lie ahead. The point I was trying to make was that Greenspan has done a bad enough job of understanding inflation and liquidity in so many instances (which I cited several of) that he is untrustworthy as an indicator of what is to come. He has recently been wrong about the inflation that supposedly was "over the horizon", and he was wrong about deflation. So thinking that he is going to suddenly start being right at this point is a premise which is in conflict with Greenspan's predictive track record.
--XXXXXXXX
#3 Vill gärna kommentera Mr A :-)
*********still-significant productivity growth and a sizable margin of underutilized resources, to date, have checked any sustained acceleration of the general price level and should continue to do so for a tim*****************
För det första CPI är upp hela 5% det senaste kvartalet annualized ,Core CPI är upp ca 3% de senaste 3 månaderna ANNU och Det som fed brukar titta på Core PCE deflator är upp 2% (3M annu)just lika mycket som FED,s inflationstarget .
För det andra med stor sannolikhet Payrolls siffror visar inte riktigt tilväxten för jobben,Greenspan har uttryckligen sagt att med tanke på andra jobb indikatorer som är väldigt positiva ,payroolls kan vara missledande och tydligen så är fallet tex small business income eller så kallade proprietor,s income är upp hela 11% Y to Y vilket visar kraften för tillväxten av nya jobb i small business som speglas inte i payrolls ,vi pratar om 100 tusen nya jobb per månad som payrolls missar.
Om jobbsiffror är underestimerade då Cap utilization är kraftigt underestimerad oxå och inte minst productivity är överestimerad .
Med tanke på att i mina ögon just nu FED,s team och Fed,s generaler är de bästa som FED har ever haft då tycker jag inte att de missar en sån grov miss av statistik som payrolls står för ,därmed talar vi om ränte höjning som stärker dollar ,drar ner guld och som sagt i början av FEb resulterar i konsol för börsen och som facit du ser själv en sån snygg triangel på S&P däremot med tanke på den eko styrkan och förbättrade vinst tillväxt ,triangeln bryter upp och inte minst den ny samlade bearish sentiment på den här sentiment chattsidan talar klar och tydlig för det .
Visa sida
Ogilla! 0
Gilla!
mao verbal räntedämpning :-)