Grupp: Huvudforum

COT Lära

0
Ogilla!
10
Gilla!
2004-05-11 05:11:34
Ladda ned

For Er som vill lära er lite om COT data - bidrar med en text och chart ifrån en känd analytiker 

*************

Date: Mon, 10 May 2004 11:04:05 -0700 

COT Report 

I have found that the best indications come from looking at what the
"commercials" are doing in terms of their net positions. They are
supposedly the "smart money" traders, although the classification of traders as "commercial", "non-commercial", or "non-reportable" is done by government bureaucrats at the CFTC, so it may be risky to place too much reliance on those classifications being absolute gospel.

Rather than looking at raw numbers, it is best to divide the commercials'
net long or short position by the total open interest so that you factor out any growth or shrinkage over time. This is the same concept as looking at an A/D ratio versus the raw A-D number.

For most futures, when the commercials go to a big net long position it is a sign of an impending uptrend. A big net short position implies an impending down move. Aside from those two conditions, it is hard to draw conclusive actionable information from the COT numbers' weekly changes. A good example of this principle is the current indication in the T-Bond commercials' net long position, shown in the first chart. Last week's ratio was among the highest ones we have seen over the past few years, and it suggests that we should join the commercials in expecting a nice up move over the next few weeks.

One point in caution is that you should always look at this data on a chart, and never rely on the raw ratio. The reason for this is that some futures contracts have an inherent short or long bias, so viewing it on a chart can help you identify where "high" and "low" exist for a particular contract. The best example of this point is silver; the COT data available from the CFTC goes back to 1986, and in all of that time, commercial silver traders have never once been net long. They have been net short by greater and lesser amounts at various times, but so far have never gone net long. This is likely due to the fact that many of the "commercials" for silver are producers who are using futures contracts as forward sales instruments.

Similarly, commercial gold futures traders have been net short (by varying amounts) since Dec. 2001, although they have been net long by large amounts at some of the great bottoms in gold prices. For crude oil futures, we have seen that a high commercials' net short position can mean a top when in a trading range, but can also be a sign of initiation when a strong uptrend is getting under way.

The SP500 (big) futures contract used to have great indications several
years ago, but recently it has not been behaving as nicely. Part of the
reason may be that there are now so many additional types of stock index futures for traders to choose from, as well as other derivatives for use in hedging strategies, and so the purity of the indications we used to see has gone away.

A while ago, I tried to investigate whether the rising popularity of the
eMini SP500 was really the diluting factor, and/or whether the other
contracts were at fault. I built a composite COT indication for all stock
index futures contracts reported in the weekly COT Report (SP500, NDX, DJIA, Russ2000, and SP400, in both the big and eMini varieties). I took each contract's raw net long positions and multiplied them by the value of each contract in dollars, then combined all of those into one indicator which is shown in the second attached chart. Sadly, I was disappointed that this conglomeration did not solve the riddle of why the SP500 COT numbers were not giving the nice indications that they did several years ago, before the advent of all of these other contracts.


What I did notice, however, and what is reflected in the construction of
this chart, is that this conglomerated COT indicator gives a pretty good
leading indication for what stock prices will do about 6 weeks later. Don't ask me why this works; it is just an observed phenomenon. It had one big period of failure back in May 2003, but other than that aberration it has done pretty well at picking turning points of significance. Perhaps someone else has an insight as to why this 6-week leading indication should work. 

You can get historical data from
http://www.cftc.gov/dea/history/deahist-cot-ftp.htm in .zip files,
expandable into Excel readable files. The weekly COT report is available at http://www.cftc.gov/dea/newcot/deafut.txt. If you open that file from within Excel and specify that you want comma delimited column breaks, then it arranges itself neatly into a spreadsheet file which can be saved for future access.

One unfortunate difficulty is that the CFTC sometimes adds or subtracts
contracts from their reporting each week. Last Friday, they deleted the
"PG&E Citygate Basis Swap-New York Mercantile Exchange" contract from the report which had been in the COT Report the week before. What this deletion does is to change the row number for every contract below it in the spreadsheet file, which makes automating the lookups in an analysis spreadsheet more difficult. Accordingly, it takes a while every week to assemble the numbers into a meaningful and useful format because of this clunky reporting methodology, and this in part is why so few of us are crazy enough to go through all the trouble to access the info in the weekly COT Reports.

0
Ogilla!
1
Gilla!
2004-05-11 09:16:24

Vad står T i T-bonds för? Treasury kanske. 

Är slutsatsen utifrån commercials netlong i T-bonds att dessa tror på en kommande räntenedgång?? Får inte ihop det riktigt.

Vh Björta

Upp till toppen
Kommentera

 

Tjäna mer pengar på dina aktieaffärer

Bli medlem på Aktieguiden gratis på 30 sekunder.

Som medlem på Aktieguiden kan du:

  • Läsa träffsäkra tips och analyser från duktiga traders
  • Ställa frågor till och chatta med aktieproffs
  • Få gratis tillgång till en över miljon inlägg aktiehandel
  • Skapa egna privata forumgrupper

För att få delta i diskussionerna på Aktieguiden krävs att du verifierar ditt mobilnummer. Läs gärna mer om varför verifiering behövs.

 

Redan medlem? Klicka här för att logga in.