Diskussioner.
Delar med mig lite av senaste snacket bland kollegor - Jag är Mr D
***************************
-----Original Message-----
Date: Fri, 7 May 2004 21:29:30 -0700
From: Mr A
Subject: Crashy market on Monday?
We could be setting up for crash-like activity on Monday, with a final bottom on Tuesday. Here is the evidence:
Friday's A/D Ratio was 266/3147, the worst one-day reading since the Oct. 27, 1997 mini-crash. But Friday is seldom the worst day of a decline.
The Oct. 27, 1997 climax bottom came on a Monday, and was on the fourth day down from a closing high. The Aug. 31, 1998 climactic bottom (A/D: 414/2886) also came on a Monday and on the fourth day down from a closing high. The breadth two days before was even worse at 378/2875. The Oct. 13, 1989 mini-crash (A/D: 153/1600) did come on a Friday, but was four days after a closing high. The Oct. 19, 1987 real crash (A/D: 52/1973) came on a Monday, and also the fourth day after a closing high. Are we detecting a trend here?
Friday?s decline was only the second day down after a closing high. That suggests that we have to wait until Tuesday to get our standard four day decline to the final low. Over the last 2 months, the recent corrective declines have been averaging 5 days from the prior closing high to the final low. As much as we hate to say it, it is not yet time to catch the falling knife. But that time is coming.
XXXXXXXXX
***********
-----Original Message-----
Date: Fri, 7 May 2004 14:32:01 -0400
From: Mr B
According to Lowry's more than half of the issues on the NYSE are not
operating company common stocks (bond funds and preferreds). Given that I would not be surprised if less than 100 common stocks (versus the 600+ issues reported) actually made new 52 lows today. Compare the NYSE to the 90+ new lows on the NASDAQ.
Also interesting is the ARMS index at about 0.6 suggests that the
balance of volume is NOT on the issues setting new lows.
XXXXX
**************
Date: Fri, 7 May 2004 15:44:32 -0400
From: Mr C
New Lows as % of Traded on a 10 Day MA basis are now about 4%. Bottoms in the 1980's & 1990's saw reading 10% or greater. In the 1970's, many in excess of 20%. It takes time to build a 10 Day MA to such extremes. I think you're a tad early to infer anything other than a very short term condition.
Certainly nothing like the magnitude of the downside spikes in 1998/2002. I would expect to see 10% or close to it on a 10 Day MA basis before I would get too excited, but I'm not a short term trader.
2 GIF's attached with history on the basis of 10 Day MA Lows % Traded. I don't buy the argument for selective screening of the data for bond funds, pfds, ETFs etc.
If it made a new low on the NYSE it was the result of sellers selling for
whatever reason. To screen out bond funds compounds a misrepresentation when markets are also being impacted by rising rates. If anything, the data was understated by the secular bond yield decline from 1985 to 2004.
XXXXXX
**************
Date: 2004 15:39:37 -0400
From: MR D
Subject: Crashy market on Monday?
To continue on Mr A's remark -
1) NYSE also penetrated the important threshold of 60%
(Percentage of stocks above their 200 DMA) - now at 51%.
The 60 level was a prior "support/resistance".
2) NASDAQ went below 50%, now at 45.5% - SP 100 at 55%.
3) Diamonds (DJIA) & Spiders (SPX) went down two days in a
row under heavy volume. Thus repeating a common theme that
sellers are in vogue and buyers are on strike.
4) DOW and SP 500 have most "likely" confirmed a symmetrical
triangle breakdown. However, the implied follow through (based on old
classics) "may" not become a reality.
5) The aggressive strength in DOLLAR (due to better than expected
non-farm payroll) has put additional pressure to the EURO / DOLLAR
trade. A weaker EURO can be expected given the failure to penetrate
the downtrend line, as well as the second breach of its 200 DMA within
2 weeks. Possible target is 117.5 followed by 115 - This is not good
for stocks since a weaker DOLLAR has been a key bull argument.
6) "Aggressive" rise in rates - hardly a good apetite for buyers.
ON A POSITIVE NOTE
1) DOW 200 DMA is at 10,002 - Old school says when
price hits a rising MA, that should be regarded as a buy signal.
2) Additional buy support at 10,000 becuase of the
psychological level; and the prior successful test in March.
3) Based on the current estimate for Q1 SP 500 earnings, the
12 month (trailing) earnings yield is at 5.30% vs. 10Y bond
at 4.76% - thus, stocks could be under valued by 11% given
the historical spread between Fed Funds and 10 Y bond at
3%. Furthermore, the P/C ratio for bonds is currently at 23.5
This ratio is the equivalent of the P/E ratio. Either rates would
have to increase further more, or stocks would have to go up
in order to narrow the gap between stocks (P/E 18.7) and
bonds. Assuming the Fed pumps it up to 1.50 over the next
6 months, that still leaves the spread with the 10Y bond above
its historical average. In other words, bond rates (short/intermediate)
"could" have a limited upside given that inflation (or unit labor costs)
does not turn into a space shuttle on steroids.
4) Continued drop in the stock market (SP 500) adds further
P/E compression - current trailing at 18.7, and forward 2004 at
16.4 (Based on First Call estimates)
XXXXXXX
*************
Date: 17:24:31 -0400
From: Mr D
To: Mr C
".....If it made a new low on the NYSE it was the result of
sellers selling for whatever reason.To screen out bond funds
compounds a misrepresentation when markets are also being
impacted by rising rates. If anything, the data was understated
by the secular bond yield decline from 1985 to 2004...."
Perhaps a better method than NYSE "new lows"
(due to bond funds) could be the percentage of stocks
moving above/below its 200 DMA - I specifically used this
measure on January 19th (days before the initial drop on the DOW)
when the stat was at record high 92 percent.
This measure is excellent for finding key turning points
when the markethas reached extreme levels. Moreover,
specific levels "can" be judged as make it, or break it.
For instance, I highlighted (in a letter) the 60 percent level on the
NYSE as key support - a violation below 60% would signal
a downturn in full force. Thursday last week the measure
bounce off 60.32 - on Friday it made a clean break below 60,
down to 51%, as decliners crushed advancers by 12 to 1.
XXXXXX
***************
Date: May 2004 17:59:45 -0400
From: Mr E
Although the OCO A/D line may or may not be the right measure, if we are
dealing with very different lists of stocks as far as make-up between now
and in the past, then we are not really comparing apples with apples.
Preferred stocks and fixed income funds have different correlations with
other issues. If we measure the percentage of stocks of all types (operating
companies, preferred, bond funds, etc) and weighted them according to some
historical average, we would probably have a better and more reliable A/D
line than we currently have.
Interest rates, depending on where we are in the business cycle, can move
with or against stocks. Selling is not just selling. Sometimes there are
money flows from one asset class to another. If that asset class is getting
commingled with the one you are trying to measure, then to count them
together is probably misleading and incorrect.
There is certainly information in having interest rate oriented securities
in the A/D list, and by throwing them out, we might be discarding the baby
with the bath water, but if their weight becomes too much of a factor, then
we are probably not looking at what we think we are looking at.
XXXXXXX
**************